Emma Frankland – No Apologies: Intentional, Powerful - SNACK: Music, film, arts and culture magazine for Scotland

Emma Frankland – No Apologies: Intentional, Powerful

Emma Frankland shapeshifts between pop-culture and storytelling, a modern-day Kurt Cobain and Death-Doula retelling Icarus. This might seem like a lot of keywords in one sentence, but her performance in No Apologies, directed by Harry Clayton-Wright, is a clear and impactful cross-section of intersectional lives through ritual, art, memory, and identity. The show is described as a ‘radical queer mis-remembering’ of Nirvana’s MTV Unplugged performance, which took place five months before the frontman, Kurt Cobain, died in 1993.

I wasn’t expecting to be moved like I was thirty-three years later. 

Fans of Nirvana might recognise the staging’s musical reference, but the visual effects of the show go deeper. Frankland remembers the MTV show and the news of Cobain’s death in the performance, describing it as the ‘first vigil’ she held, but not the last. Read in reference to the deaths and murders of trans and gender non-conformists. 

Remembering and recreating the 1993 performance set really lent to a memorial atmosphere with flowers and black candles. A kind of ritual holding-of-space that reminded me of Ana Mendieta’s 1976 piece, with Black Ritual Candles arranged in the outline of a body. This crossed into wax-play-performance-art, as Franklin poured the candles over her shoulders to create dark wings, before further exploring this imagery of dark or deathly angel guiding each transition. This combination of personal depression, grief, and life-expectancy was well illustrated with the myth of Icarus in the climax. Here, the imagery helped clarify connections within the performance.

The show was directed to combine elements of fire, water, air, and earth, to conjure a kind of ritualistic memorial. There were real flames in the candles and enough haze to warrant a warning – it whistled like wind between headstones in any stretch of silence. The floral pieces of the staging represented earth, and water was used to clean ash and char from fires and faces, after the track began to glitch and loop. The spiritual semiotics transcended from performance to ritual container for the exploration, which helped create an atmosphere that was slightly liminal, ‘other’, much like the feelings the audience were invited to embrace.

Emma shifted persona to explore identity in each phase of the performance, starting with the iconic Cobain sunglasses, cardigan, and white mug all created an identity in connection and memorial for the late frontman. 

But as the performance becomes deeper and vulnerable, the artist’s visual identity matches. When reflecting on her appearance as a signifier of trans identity, and shame surrounding it, Frankland stripped off the Cobain Costume, baring her breasts. A challenging but vulnerable show of identity, my head went straight to safety and concern and the current climate. But the sacred container had already been set. 

Such a complex consideration of identity was handled with an irresistible cheekiness and joy for life that was difficult not to be inspired by. My favourite example of this bold identity was ‘Go home and crossdress tonight, it might destroy your life, and that might change the world’.

Why tie in a story of queer identity to Cobain’s icon status? Because who we get to see creating in front of us could change our lives. Emma and the director both grew up in seaside towns, liminal between tourist seasons, just like Kurt Cobain. Their upbringing was also during Section 28 and the AIDS crisis, meaning many queer elders never got to leave examples for the younger generation to follow. As Frankland self-describes as the new generation of trans elders, this also creates a hope in a new kind of artist to look up to. One that intentionally considered audience and accessibility in great collaboration with the venue, captioned and audio-considered/described throughout.

This audience were engaged like the chorus in a Greek play, or certainly the concert crowd, cheering when prompted. We were asked to think of a celebrity that was important to us as teenagers, and to reflect on what would happen if we, or Emma as a young teen, saw trans icons on stage at fourteen years old. To see that you’re not alone – how much could this change? Is this wishful thinking? Should we think wishfully regardless before diminishing it?

The big takeaway was this ‘Wishful Thinking and Talking’. Conjuring and re-defining a world you want to inhabit, with intention and confidence, just like the creators of No Apologies did. And so, every night they ask us to imagine something different. No apologies. Intentional, powerful. 

An iconic exploration of gender and ‘othered’ experiences.

‘What else should I write?’

No Apologies, Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh, 12th-13th November 2026